Investors today face a daunting challenge: most mutual funds fail to beat the market. As the market grows increasingly concentrated around a handful of mega-cap stocks, passive strategies are likely to face headwinds over the coming decade. Amid these challenges, one fund dares to be different—offering a thoughtful, unconventional approach. Enter Mohnish Pabrai, a renowned value investor known for making bold, high-conviction bets. His new Pabrai Wagons Fund might just be the alternative investors need to outperform in an era of diminished returns.
Why Most Mutual Funds Fall Short
The odds of beating the market are slim. According to the latest SPIVA (S&P Indices versus Active) report, 71% of U.S.-domiciled funds investing in global equities underperformed their benchmarks in the first half of 2024, with 86% lagging over the past five years, and 88% falling short over the past ten years.
This lag can be attributed to two key factors: fees and lack of differentiation. Many mutual funds buy the same core stocks—particularly those dominating major indices like the S&P 500. With giants like Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet (Google’s parent), Amazon, NVIDIA, Meta Platforms, and Tesla often topping their portfolios, these funds end up closely mimicking the index. However, the added burden of management fees eats into returns, resulting in net underperformance.
David Kostin, Chief U.S. Equity Strategist at Goldman Sachs, recently projected that the S&P 500 may deliver a meager 3% nominal annual return over the next decade, significantly below its historical averages. This return would place it among the bottom 7% of all 10-year periods since 1930. He warns that today’s extremely high market concentration, which ranks near the highest level in 100 years, poses significant risks for index-heavy strategies that rely on a few mega-cap stocks to drive returns. According to Kostin, portfolios with more differentiation and equal-weighted strategies are likely to outperform cap-weighted benchmarks over the coming years.
Mohnish Pabrai: The Guru with a Winning Formula
Mohnish Pabrai, a legendary value investor, has built his reputation through his hedge fund, Pabrai Investment Funds. Inspired by Warren Buffett’s value investing principles, Pabrai’s fund for accredited investors has delivered exceptional returns—gaining 12.9% annually after fees from July 1, 1999 through September 30, 2024 compared to 7.8% for the S&P 500 with dividends reinvested—by making concentrated bets on undervalued companies and holding them patiently. His success lies in buying businesses with sustainable competitive advantages, strong free cash flows, and high returns on equity—all at modest valuations.
Pabrai has shared his insights through multiple channels, including his bestselling book The Dhandho Investor and the popular Chai with Pabrai podcast and blog, where he continues to engage with followers and investors interested in his philosophy.
The Pabrai Wagons Fund: A Strategy Built to Outlast the Market
In September 2023, Pabrai launched the Pabrai Wagons Fund—WAGNX (retail class) and WGNIX (institutional class). The fund marks an exciting shift, giving everyday investors access to Pabrai’s unique investment approach for the first time. As of its first anniversary on September 30, 2024, the fund was up approximately 26%, lagging the S&P 500’s 36% climb over the same period. However, it’s essential to note that one year is too short a timeframe to judge the fund’s potential accurately.
In fact, the surge in the Magnificent 7 stocks that has been the main driver of the S&P 500’s recent gains has left the index trading at a frothy trailing P/E of over 25. Notably, the S&P 500’s current valuation even exceeds its P/E ratio before the dot-com bubble burst in 2000, reinforcing Kostin’s forecast that index-heavy strategies could struggle over the next decade.
Contrast this with the Wagons Fund, which avoids chasing short-term trends like AI and focuses instead on misunderstood, undervalued sectors that could thrive as market dynamics shift. A glance at the fund’s portfolio reveals this differentiation: unconventional bets like Turkish stocks and coal companies stand out among its top holdings, setting it apart from the tech-heavy portfolios currently driving the S&P 500. With an underlying portfolio sporting a trailing P/E of less than 8, this divergence from traditional fund compositions suggests that the Wagons Fund could outperform as today’s market darlings eventually cool.
A Savvy Pick for Investors Ready to Move Beyond the Herd
For investors seeking alternatives to index funds and underperforming conventional mutual funds, the Pabrai Wagons Fund presents an intriguing option. With its unique holdings and adherence to a disciplined, time-tested philosophy, it offers the potential for uncorrelated returns in a concentrated market environment. The fund may not have beaten the S&P 500 in its first year, but its differentiated strategy makes it a compelling candidate for long-term investors looking beyond the crowded space of U.S. mega-cap stocks.
Hungry for more investment ideas like the Pabrai Wagons Fund? Don’t miss my take on why Lakeland Industries (LAKE) might be a great buy right now.